Use this comparison within Ownership costs and alternatives.
A cheaper repair with a shorter useful life
Read expected cost before annual cost
- Expected repair cost
- Immediate repair plus possible follow-up cost weighted by its entered probability.
- Repair cost per year
- Expected repair-path cost spread across estimated remaining years.
- Replacement cost per year
- Replacement price minus resale and operating savings, spread across useful years.
Whether repair or replacement costs less
The calculator estimates the repair path after allowing for a possible follow-up failure, then compares it with the net replacement path. Converting both to cost per useful year prevents a long-lived replacement from being judged only by its larger upfront price.
Compare repair and replacement over the same period
Use the next useful years and ignore money already spent. Include diagnosis, downtime and temporary substitutes when they differ between paths.
Annualized cost does not capture reliability or cash pressure. Keep the emergency-buffer effect and consequence of another failure beside the result.
- Use a qualified diagnosis and a realistic remaining life after repair.
- Include setup, disposal, downtime and operating differences when material.
- Keep safety and essential reliability separate from the lowest-cost calculation.
How unequal useful lives become comparable
Comparison method
Expected repair cost includes follow-up cost times probability. Each path is converted to an annualized net cost across its expected useful period.
Use the repair or replace decision guide to handle safety, reliability and timing factors that a cost comparison cannot decide. Model the replacement with the replacement ownership-cost estimate before treating its purchase price as the complete alternative.
When a service contract is offered with the replacement, assess its expected covered repair value and exclusions separately.
Repair-versus-replace comparison errors
- Including money already spent as a future repair cost
- Assuming one repair restores the item to new condition
- Comparing a short repair extension with a long replacement life using upfront cost alone
When cost should not decide repair or replacement
The estimate cannot determine safety, repair quality, parts availability, environmental impact or the consequence of another failure. A qualified inspection is necessary for vehicles, electrical systems, medical equipment and other safety-critical items.