Use this comparison within Financing and borrowing.
A lower payment that takes three years to recover
Read recovery time and added debt together
- Monthly payment saving
- Current payment minus the proposed new payment.
- Simple break-even
- Refinancing cost divided by monthly payment saving.
- Holding-period benefit
- Cumulative saving during the expected period after costs and added debt.
When refinancing begins to save cash
The result separates the recovery month from the expected holding-period benefit. It also identifies balance added to the new loan so payment savings are not mistaken for debt reduction.
Compare the loan at the planned exit date
Compare Loan Estimates with the same lock period and loan purpose. A lower payment created mainly by restarting a long term can increase lifetime interest.
Use the break-even date only when you expect to keep the loan beyond it. Also compare balances at the planned exit date, not only monthly cash flow.
- Use comparable Loan Estimates with the same loan purpose.
- Check balances and total interest at the month you expect to leave.
- Reject a break-even that occurs after the likely sale or next refinance.
How payment savings recover costs
Comparison method
Simple break-even divides refinancing cost by monthly payment saving. Period cash-flow benefit multiplies the saving across the expected holding months and subtracts refinancing cost and added debt.
Use the APR and interest-rate guide to compare formal disclosures. Put both payment schedules into the loan comparison calculator.
Refinancing comparisons that hide cost
- Calling financed closing cost free
- Judging savings only by the new monthly payment
- Restarting a long term without comparing the future balance
Limits of a simple refinance break-even
The calculation does not model full amortization, taxes, adjustable rates, opportunity cost or changes in mortgage insurance. It treats payment savings as constant. Use lender disclosures and an exit-date amortization comparison before proceeding.